Skip to content
St. Louis, Missouri Local weather
VOTP NEWSST. LOUIS

Your voice in today’s world.
Local news. Community. Culture.

BREAKINGWoman Charged After Alleged Threats Against Pattonville Heights Middle SchoolAll updates →
Home / Crime Watch
Crime Watch

Carthage man previously identified as NXT Level Media co-owner faces felony cocaine charge

Court records show a Class D felony cocaine possession charge against Toby Jay Hulstine. A 2021 Joplin Chamber record identified Hulstine as a co-owner of NXT Level Media LLC.

Heavily blurred portrait supplied for an article about a Jasper County criminal case
Submitted image, digitally obscured for editorial use. Original photographer not identified; usage rights not confirmed.

CARTHAGE, Mo. — Toby Jay Hulstine, a Carthage man identified in earlier business records as a co-owner of the sports media company NXT Level Media LLC, has been charged with felony possession of a controlled substance in Jasper County, according to court documents reviewed by VOTP News STL.

The charge, listed as a Class D felony under Missouri Revised Statute 579.015, stems from a July 25 incident outside a Walmart at 2705 S. Grand Ave. in Carthage. The criminal case is State of Missouri v. Toby Jay Hulstine, 26AP-CR01279.

What police allege

In a probable cause statement dated October 29, Carthage police Cpl. Jaccob Ransome wrote that he responded to Walmart after an employee found a suspicious substance near the store’s south exit.

Ransome said he reviewed store surveillance footage and recognized Hulstine from previous interactions. According to the officer, the footage showed the substance falling from Hulstine’s right pocket. Police collected approximately 3.3 grams of material, which the officer said was later confirmed as cocaine through laboratory testing.

The officer reported contacting Hulstine at a local Quality Inn, where Hulstine allegedly consented to a search. Police reported finding a rolled dollar bill containing a white powder they suspected was cocaine residue. According to the statement, Hulstine initially denied knowledge of the substance recovered at Walmart but later told officers it was cocaine.

The statement also describes additional items found during a consent search of a hotel room, including dollar bills and small plastic bags with white powder residue. The document does not establish that all of those items were separately laboratory-tested. Although paraphernalia is mentioned in the officer’s narrative, the charge displayed in the provided court record is felony controlled-substance possession.

Police said Hulstine was not arrested at the time of the July incident. That statement does not independently establish his current custody status.

Connection to NXT Level Media

An April 2021 membership announcement from the Joplin Area Chamber of Commerce identifies Toby Hulstine and Ty Hulstine as co-owners of NXT Level Media LLC, describing the business as a media production and internet news source. The company has been associated with coverage of area athletics, including school sports. The 2021 record establishes historical ownership; VOTP News STL has not independently confirmed the company’s current ownership.

Nothing in the probable cause statement alleges criminal activity involving NXT Level Media, a school, student-athletes or sporting events.

Case status

A December 14, 2026, court appearance was reported in information accompanying the court documents, but VOTP News STL has not independently verified that hearing date through the current docket. The case may be searched through Missouri Case.net using case number 26AP-CR01279.

VOTP News STL has not obtained a response from Hulstine or his attorney. The allegations are unproven, and Hulstine is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.

Featured image: Submitted portrait, digitally blurred for editorial presentation. Original photographer unidentified.

Share this storyEmailFacebook

Leave a Reply

More to Read

View all
VOTP Radio
Ready to play