Skip to content
St. Louis, Missouri Local weather
VOTP NEWSST. LOUIS

Your voice in today’s world.
Local news. Community. Culture.

Home / Crime Watch
Crime Watch

Warren County jury finds Timothy Shields guilty in baseball bat assault

A Warren County jury found Timothy Michael Shields guilty of first-degree domestic assault and armed criminal action. Sentencing is set for January 27, 2027.

Photo supplied with the announcement about Timothy Michael Shields.
Timothy Michael Shields. Photo provided to VOTP News STL.

WARREN COUNTY, Mo. — A Warren County jury found Timothy Michael Shields guilty of first-degree domestic assault and armed criminal action on November 13, according to an announcement from Warren County Prosecuting Attorney Rodney McKinney.

The two felony convictions stem from a 2023 incident in which Shields beat his former girlfriend with a baseball bat, the announcement said.

Update — November 16, 2026, 12:21 p.m. CST: VOTP News STL obtained the redacted probable cause statement filed September 5, 2023, in Warren County case 23BB-CR00517. In the document, Warrenton police alleged Shields repeatedly struck his former girlfriend with an aluminum baseball bat, forced her to bind her ankles with an extension cord and withheld her cellphone. The filing describes severe injuries, including fractures that required surgery. The statement also listed a kidnapping allegation; however, the prosecutor’s November 13, 2026, announcement reported guilty verdicts for first-degree domestic assault and armed criminal action. The probable cause statement records investigative allegations and is not itself a jury verdict. Read the official redacted probable cause statement (Missouri Courts PDF).

“Shields faces a potential maximum sentence of 45 years in the Missouri Department of Corrections,” the announcement said.

Sentencing is scheduled for January 27, 2027, before Judge Jonathan Yelton. The 45-year figure is the potential maximum identified by prosecutors; Shields has not yet been sentenced in the case, according to the announcement.

Missouri’s armed criminal action statute covers committing a felony through the use of a dangerous instrument or deadly weapon. The offense does not require the use of a firearm.

Source: Warren County Prosecuting Attorney Rodney McKinney, written announcement. Statutory reference: Missouri Revised Statutes, Section 571.015, version in effect in 2023.

Share this storyEmailFacebook

Leave a Reply

More to Read

View all
VOTP Radio
Ready to play